DIY Ads vs Hiring an Agency – How to Decide

byclientdev
February 2, 2026

How many decisions do you make each day? If you’re running a business, that number could easily be in the hundreds. And you can probably place each decision into one of two categories:
1. Will it make money for the company?
2. Will it save the company money?

But some things aren’t always so black and white.

Let’s take a look at advertising. Expanding your company’s visibility is key to attracting more customers and boosting profits. However, advertising costs money, which goes against minimizing expenses.

Your solution: save money on advertising by doing it yourself.

Before you spend your time and money on DIY ads, take a few minutes to discover what’s truly at stake.

Where’s Your Focus?

Your business is providing a product or service to your customers. If you want your business to grow, then you need more customers. To get those customers, you need to advertise.

But marketing goes way beyond just “running some ads.” By choosing to do it yourself, you are also choosing:

  • Learning platforms
  • Watching metrics
  • Writing copy
  • Fixing tracking
  • Testing creatives

Now, you’ve become a part-time marketer.

Hiring an ad agency means you get to stay in your zone of genius and focus on what matters the most: your product.

DIY Looks Cheaper – Until You Count Opportunity Lost

What’s your time worth? There are only twenty-four hours in a day, and running a business requires you to get the maximum amount of value from each hour. When business owners decide to run ads themselves, they rarely factor in the value of their own time. Dozens of hours are spent learning ad platforms, building campaigns, writing copy, and monitoring performance. That’s time not spent serving clients, closing sales, and leading the business.

You also need to consider the wasted ad dollars spent while learning. Mistakes are expensive. With DIY ads, it’s common to burn through the budget on poorly targeted audiences, weak creatives, or misconfigured conversions.

In contrast, agencies bring experience that helps avoid costly trial-and-error. Your ad dollars are working efficiently right from the start.

Agencies Bring Pattern Recognition

When you run your own ads, you have a single window: your account. Every decision you make is made in isolation, based on what you tried before and guessing what might work next.

An agency doesn’t have that limitation because it brings pattern recognition. It’s what comes from seeing the same problems repeat across dozens of accounts, hundreds of funnels, and thousands of data points. They know which creative angles reliably convert, which strategies quietly fail, and which optimizations actually matter and which ones are just noise.

An agency’s experience changes how decisions are made. Their perspective is practical and powerful.

Does DIY Ever Make Sense?

DIY advertising can be the smart move, as long as expectations align with reality.

If your monthly ad budget is under $1,000, it may not make financial sense to pay an ad agency. The stakes are relatively low, and hands-on experimentation can be a good way to explore whether paid ads have potential for your business.

DIY also makes sense when you’re still validating an offer. Running your own ads can help you understand market response, which messages resonate with your audience, and if there’s real demand before you invest heavily.

There’s also value in wanting a foundational understanding of how advertising works. Learning the basics of targeting, creative copy, funnels, and metrics can make you a better decision-maker. It’s particularly true if you genuinely enjoy the tinkering, testing, and analyzing data that make up marketing.

DIY builds literacy. You learn the language and understand what questions to ask.

But literacy isn’t mastery.

Running a few ads isn’t the same as scaling a campaign, managing volatility, or diagnosing performance issues. True mastery comes from running many accounts across multiple scenarios over time.

Don’t Miss the Transition Point

There’s a moment when DIY advertising quietly quits working, and most businesses miss it.
It doesn’t quit working because it’s failing, but because it’s starting to succeed. That’s when the margin for error shrinks. Small mistakes that used to cost a few dollars now cost hundreds of thousands.

Now decisions get more complex and involve budgets, creative direction, and audience overlap. They are based on data, not guesses. But that data isn’t as simple as ad platforms make it appear.

Testing speed becomes critical. Winning campaigns don’t come about by making occasional tweaks. They’ve uncovered through disciplined, continuous experimentation. But when the founder is still personally managing the ads, everything slows down. Every change competes with sales calls, client work, and leadership responsibilities. The founder becomes the bottleneck.

That’s the moment to bring in support.

Not because everything is broken and panic sets in.

It’s when things are starting to work, and you have something worth protecting and optimizing. At that stage, an agency isn’t trying to control chaos; it’s turning your early success into sustainable growth.

Recent Posts

What is Yoast, and How Can it Benefit Your Business?

Are you looking for a way to improve your business’s online visibility? We all know how important it is to have a robust online presence. But what if your website isn’t optimized for organic search ranking? You could be missing out on valuable leads and sales. That’s...

Why All Attorneys Should Get Google Verified

Most attorneys understand the challenges they face in regards to showing up in Google search results. There’s a lot of competition between law firms locally. It can be difficult to stand out, even when you know you offer top quality law services. How can you convince...

Episode 15: Zach Spuckler Disrupting The Internet Marketing Industry

In this episode, Michael chats with digital course creator, Zach Spuckler about earning six figures in his twenties with digital courses. Learn how Zach is disrupting this industry with his prices and his digital course content. Are digital courses on the way out? Is...

Episode 13: Marketing Professional Services Online

There are 8 specific areas every service-based business must address in order to get the most out of online marketing.  This show has been specifically designed for businesses that offer professional services to local residents and companies.  So, whether you’re just...

Episode 11: The Wrong Sales Can Hurt Your Business

In this episode, Michael breaks down why not all business is created equal, and how the wrong business can actually hurt you in the long run.  Service selling is the equivalent of getting into a romantic relationship.  Not that you’re hooking up with clients.  But...

Episode 10: From TV Producer To Digital Agency Owner

In this episode Michael and special guest, Jennifer Sunnerton of Moko Media, discuss how to pivot careers and take the plunge into Entrepreneurship.  From diving in with no sales experience to why it’s crucial to selectively choose your clients from the jump, Michael...

ready to see the truth
in your ad spend?

Stop leaving it to chance. Let’s review your account, uncover the leaks, and position your business for growth.